This is Part 2 of our guide to choosing a tree service company. If you missed Part 1, read about the 5 Green Lights to look for before continuing.
You have learned what to look for in a professional tree service company—proper licensing and insurance, certified arborists, an established local presence, professional equipment, and written estimates. But knowing what makes a good tree service is only half the equation. You also need to recognize the warning signs that should send you looking elsewhere.
At MMP Tree Service, we have heard countless stories from Atlanta homeowners who learned these lessons the hard way. This guide covers the five major red flags that indicate you are dealing with an unprofessional or potentially fraudulent tree service company, plus practical advice on pricing, getting estimates, and protecting yourself.
Red Flag #1: Door‑to‑door solicitation
Be extremely wary of tree service crews that knock on your door offering to do work, especially right after storms. Common scenarios:
- “We were working nearby and noticed you have a dead tree…”
- “We have leftover time/materials from another job…”
- “We can give you a deal if you hire us today…”
While some legitimate companies do market this way, many storm‑chasing fly‑by‑night operators use this tactic. They pressure you into quick decisions, may not be properly insured, and often disappear before finishing the work or after causing damage.
What to do: It is fine to get an estimate from someone who approaches you, but do not sign contracts or pay deposits on the spot. Do your due diligence—check their insurance, verify they are a real company, and get references. Never feel pressured to make an immediate decision about tree work unless there is a genuine safety emergency.
Red Flag #2: Cash‑only payments or large upfront deposits
Payment terms say a lot about a company’s legitimacy:
Legitimate practices:
- Accept checks, credit cards, or online payments
- Request payment upon completion or 50% deposit for very large jobs
- Provide receipts and invoices for all transactions
Red flags:
- Cash only, no receipts
- Require full payment before starting work
- Want payment before cleanup is complete
- No written contract or invoice
Companies that insist on cash are often avoiding taxes, may not be properly licensed, and give you no paper trail if something goes wrong. Companies demanding full payment upfront sometimes take the money and disappear, or do substandard work knowing you have no leverage once they have been paid.
What to do: Pay by check or credit card whenever possible—this creates documentation and provides recourse if there are problems. Never pay the full amount until the work is complete and you have inspected the results. Standard practice is to pay upon completion or, for very large jobs, 50% upfront and 50% when finished.
Red Flag #3: “Topping” or extreme pruning recommendations
Tree “topping”—cutting off the entire top of a tree to reduce height—is outdated, harmful, and considered malpractice by certified arborists. Topped trees:
- Are more likely to die from the stress and wounds
- Develop weak new growth that breaks easily
- Become ugly and disfigured
- Are more susceptible to disease and pests
Any company that recommends topping (except in rare utility line situations) does not understand proper tree care.
Similarly, be suspicious if a company wants to remove much more of a tree than seems necessary. Excessive pruning (more than 25% of the canopy) stresses trees and can lead to decline.
What to do: If a company recommends topping or aggressive pruning, get a second opinion from a certified arborist. Proper tree care focuses on selective pruning that maintains tree health and structure. MMP Tree Service follows ISA standards and never recommends topping except in extraordinary circumstances.
Red Flag #4: No proof of insurance
We mentioned this in Part 1 under “green lights,” but it deserves its own red flag section because it is so important. According to industry estimates, up to 30% of tree service companies operating in the U.S. are uninsured or underinsured.
If a worker falls from a tree on your property and the company has no workers’ comp insurance, you could be sued for their medical bills and lost wages. If their equipment damages your house and they have no liability insurance, you will have to file a claim with your own homeowner’s policy (and pay your deductible).
Companies that are uninsured usually offer the lowest prices because they have lower overhead. But that low price comes with enormous risk transferred to you.
What to do: Always—always—verify insurance before allowing any tree work to begin. Call the insurance company directly using the phone number on the certificate (not one provided by the tree company) and confirm the policy is active and covers the work being done. Do not take “we’re insured, trust us” as an answer.
Red Flag #5: Highball estimates followed by sudden “discounts”
Some companies use manipulative sales tactics:
“Your tree removal will cost $5,000. But because I like you, and we are slow this week, I can do it for $2,000 if you sign today.”
This artificial urgency is designed to prevent you from getting other estimates or thinking critically about the decision. Legitimate companies price jobs fairly from the start and do not play these games.
What to do: Never feel pressured to make an immediate decision. Get multiple estimates and take time to compare them. If a company is legitimate and professional, they will still be available next week. If they pressure you to “decide now or lose this price,” thank them and move on to someone else.
What affects tree service costs
Understanding typical pricing helps you spot unrealistic bids:
Factors that increase cost:
- Proximity to structures or power lines
- Difficult access or terrain
- Tree condition (dead, damaged, hazardous)
- Debris removal and cleanup requirements
- Need for cranes or specialized equipment
If a bid is significantly lower than others, ask why. It could be a legitimate reason (slower season, efficient operations) or a red flag (no insurance, cutting corners, inexperienced crew).
What if something goes wrong?
Even with reputable companies, issues occasionally arise. If you have a problem:
- Contact the company immediately – Most issues can be resolved with a simple phone call.
- Document the problem – Take photos of any damage or concerns.
- Review your contract – Understand what was agreed upon.
- Be reasonable – Some minor imperfections are normal with tree work.
- Escalate if needed – If the company will not address legitimate concerns, file a complaint with the Better Business Bureau or consider small claims court.
Companies with proper insurance should cover any legitimate property damage. Having that insurance documentation up front gives you recourse if problems occur.
Trust your instincts
After all the research, insurance verification, and reference checking, listen to your gut. If something about a company or crew feels wrong—they are pushy, unprofessional, vague, or make you uncomfortable—find someone else.
Tree work requires trust. You are allowing people onto your property with dangerous equipment, often when you are not home. Work with a company that makes you feel confident and comfortable from the first contact through completion.
Make the smart choice for your Atlanta property
Now you know both what to look for (the five green lights from Part 1) and what to avoid (the five red flags in Part 2). Armed with this knowledge, you can confidently choose a tree service company that will protect your property, respect your investment, and deliver professional results.
The difference between a professional, ethical company and a fly‑by‑night operator comes down to:
✓ Licensing and insurance
✓ Certified expertise
✓ Established reputation
✓ Professional equipment
✓ Transparent pricing
✓ Ethical practices
Cutting corners by hiring the cheapest option—or worse, an uninsured crew—may save money upfront but can cost you thousands if something goes wrong.
Choose wisely, choose MMP Tree Service
MMP Tree Service avoids all five red flags and displays all five green lights:
- ✓ Fully licensed and insured (certificates provided on request)
- ✓ Certified arborists on staff
- ✓ Over 12 years serving the Atlanta metro area
- ✓ Professional equipment and trained crews
- ✓ Honest, transparent pricing with written estimates
- ✓ No pressure tactics or high-pressure sales
- ✓ Family-owned and locally operated
Get started with a free estimate today:
- Call (470) 403-0215 to speak with a tree care professional
- Request an online estimate at your convenience
- Ask about our current projects and customer references
Do not settle for less than professional, safe, ethical tree service. Your property, your family’s safety, and your peace of mind deserve the best. Choose MMP Tree Service for tree care you can trust.
If you missed Part 1, read about the 5 Green Lights to look for when hiring a tree service company in Atlanta.
About MMP Tree Service LLC
MMP Tree Service is a family‑owned tree care company serving Acworth, Canton, Alpharetta, Roswell, and the greater Atlanta metro area. With certified arborists, comprehensive insurance, state‑of‑the‑art equipment, and over a decade of local experience, MMP Tree Service provides safe, professional tree removal, trimming, and emergency services. Licensed, insured, and committed to customer satisfaction.
Related Services: